How to run an agency RFP that actually gets you the right partner

Most agency RFPs fail before the first agency reads them. A vague brief goes out to ten studios, proposals come back impossible to compare, and the decision ends up resting on whoever ran the best slideshow.
TL;DR Align internally first, write a precise brief, invite three to five agencies, never ask for free creative work, and score proposals against criteria you set in advance.
As a brand and website studio, KLIMB takes part in RFPs regularly. The best ones share the same traits: a clear problem, an honest budget, a short list of agencies, and a process that respects everyone's time. The worst ones look like a shopping list sent to the whole market. This guide covers how to run the first kind.
What should you settle internally before sending an RFP?
Five things: the business problem, who decides, who must be consulted, the real budget and the deadline.
Most confusing RFPs reflect a confused organization. If marketing wants a rebrand, sales wants a new website and the CEO wants "something bolder", agencies will each pick a different reading, and you'll compare answers to three different questions.
Before writing anything, get answers to these:
- What problem are we solving? "Our brand no longer reflects what we sell" is a problem. "We need a new logo" is a solution, and maybe the wrong one.
- Who makes the final call? Name the decision makers and involve them from the first meeting, not the last.
- Who else needs a say? Employees, local teams, a board, a parent company. In one RFP we answered, the client realized after sending it that the marketing committee would never sign off without consulting staff. Better to plan that step from day one than to bolt it on mid-project.
- What can we actually spend? An approximate range is enough. It's the single piece of information that most changes the quality of the answers.
- When do we need it, and what does it depend on? A funding round, a product launch or a website going live gives the timeline a reason, and agencies will plan around it.
One internal workshop of two hours usually covers all five. It's the best-spent time of the whole process.
What should a good RFP brief include?
Where you start, where you want to go, what's in scope, your constraints, budget, timeline and how you'll decide.
A good brief fits in a few pages. Agencies don't need everything on day one; they need enough to understand the problem and propose a credible approach.
- Company context. What you sell, to whom, your stage and what has changed recently (funding, new market, new product, an acquisition).
- Where you start, where you want to go. One of the clearest briefs we received this year had a short section with exactly this title: today's situation in four lines, then the criteria for success. Agencies understood the gap instantly.
- The options you've ruled out. If several directions are possible, list them and say which extremes you exclude. It gives agencies room to think while keeping them inside your boundaries.
- A precise scope. Count the deliverables (how many logos, templates, pages, languages) and ask for a price line per item. That's what makes proposals comparable.
- Existing material. Personas, brand narrative, current guidelines, previous research. Share it as PDFs, not in formats some agencies can't open.
- Constraints and dependencies. Technical stack, CMS, licensing rules (free fonts, for example), and any other supplier involved. If a separate agency builds the website, say so and ask for a coordination method.
- Budget range and timeline. Including key milestones and any fixed date.
- Process and criteria. One contact for questions, the deadline, what you expect at this stage, who's in the room and how proposals will be scored.
Add one thing most briefs forget: what you've already tried and why it didn't work. It saves agencies from proposing what you've already ruled out.
How many agencies should you invite to an RFP?
Three to five for the written proposal, two or three for the final round. More agencies means weaker answers, not better choice.
The market has largely converged on this. In a FindGood survey of almost 500 UK client marketers and 500 agencies, reported by The Drum in 2025, more than 80% of clients said three agencies was the maximum they would shortlist for a pitch.
The reason is simple: the best agencies choose which RFPs they answer. When they see a list of ten competitors, many decline or send a generic proposal. A short list signals that you've done your homework and that the effort is worth it.
To build that list, start wider and filter before the RFP goes out:
- Look at work, not claims. Shortlist agencies whose recent projects look like the problem you're trying to solve.
- Hold 30-minute intro calls. You'll learn more about fit, seniority and chemistry than from any credentials deck.
- Tell agencies who else is in the running, at least how many. It helps them calibrate their investment.
Only then send the full brief to the agencies you'd genuinely be happy to work with.
What does a well-run RFP look like, step by step?
Ten steps, from the brief to the kick-off. Most clients stop thinking at the decision, but steps six to ten decide how fast the project starts.
Here's the sequence we walk clients through at KLIMB. It works whether you run a formal tender or a lighter consultation.
- Brief. You share the brief and key documents, and both sides agree on the schedule.
- Discovery call. A first conversation to get to know each other, walk through the brief and align on expectations.
- Presentation. The agency presents its approach, method and relevant case studies, ideally in person.
- Scope and budget. Deliverables are detailed and matched against your budget, openly.
- Reference check. You talk to the agency's past and current clients, and sometimes its investors or partners.
- Deal. Final terms are confirmed and the roadmap is validated.
- Procurement. Decision makers are identified, the purchase order is raised and billing is set up.
- Contract. CEO, CMO, legal and finance align on the final agreement and deliverables.
- Kick-off. Stakeholders, rituals, reporting, shared workspace and project calendar.
- Company presentation (optional). A short talk at your all-hands, so the whole company knows why the project exists.
Two steps are often skipped and later regretted. The reference check takes thirty minutes and tells you more than any credentials deck. And procurement, if started only after the decision, can delay a kick-off by several weeks: involve your finance team early.
Should you ask agencies for free creative work?
No. Ask for thinking and method, not finished creative. If you want to see ideas, pay for them.
Pitching is far more expensive than most clients realize. The European Association of Communications Agencies (EACA) found in its Cost of Pitching 2025 study that the average pitch costs an agency €43,804, and agencies spend over €650,000 a year on pitches. Clients tend to underestimate this: in a PM Society survey, 39% of clients believed the average pitch cost under £5,000, while 61% of agencies reported spending more than £15,000.
Free creative also gives you a poor signal. A logo or a homepage produced in two weeks, without research, interviews or access to your team, tells you how an agency guesses, not how it works. You end up choosing on taste rather than on method.
Better alternatives:
- Ask for the approach. How would they diagnose the problem, run the strategy phase and involve your team?
- Ask for relevant case studies, explained by the people who'd actually work on your project.
- Run a paid discovery sprint with your preferred agency if you need to see work before committing.
If you do require creative, offer a pitch fee. It shows respect, and it attracts agencies that would otherwise decline.
How do you evaluate agency proposals fairly?
Set weighted criteria before proposals arrive, score each one independently, then discuss. Never the other way around.
Without a grid, the decision drifts toward the most charismatic presenter or the lowest price. With one, every stakeholder scores the same things, and disagreements become useful conversations instead of gut feelings.
Here's a grid you can adapt. Adjust the weights to your priorities, but fix them before reading a single proposal.
- Understanding of the problem (25%): do they rephrase your challenge better than your brief did?
- Method (20%): a clear process, with research, checkpoints and team involvement.
- Relevant experience (20%): similar problems solved, not just similar industries.
- Team (15%): the people who'll actually do the work, and their seniority.
- Price and scope (15%): clear deliverables, realistic timeline, value for budget.
- Chemistry (5%): would your team enjoy working with them for months?
Three habits from the best-run RFPs we've taken part in make the presentation round far more useful:
- Send your questions in writing before the presentation. One client read our proposal the morning of the meeting and sent six precise questions on scope, scenarios, references, timeline and font licensing. The meeting became a working session instead of a slideshow.
- Meet the people who'll do the work. Ask who the project manager will be and whether you'll meet them at the presentation. A pitch delivered by founders who disappear after signing tells you little about the next six months.
- Put the decision maker in the room. If your CMO or CEO signs off, they should hear the final presentations firsthand rather than through a summary.
What are the most common RFP mistakes?
Hiding the budget, inviting too many agencies, asking for spec work, rushing the timeline and giving no feedback.
An RFP isn't cheap for the client either. The Cost of the Pitch study by the 4A's, the ANA and Advertiser Perceptions (2023) estimates that a full agency review costs the client side around $400,000 in time and resources. Large reviews, admittedly, but the logic holds at any size: a messy process wastes everyone's money.
The mistakes we see most often:
- No budget range. Agencies end up guessing, and you get proposals priced from one to five times apart that can't be compared.
- A brief written for a solution. Asking for "a new website" when the real issue is positioning leads to the wrong project.
- Too short a response window. A serious proposal needs two to three weeks, including time for questions.
- Procurement-only criteria. Price matters, but scoring a strategic partnership like a commodity purchase favors the cheapest, not the best fit.
- Silence after the decision. Agencies invested real time. Clear, specific feedback costs you a 15-minute call and strengthens your reputation as a client.
Good agencies talk to each other. The way you run your RFP shapes who answers the next one.
Frequently asked questions
How long should an agency RFP process take?
Around four to eight weeks from brief to decision. The response window depends on what you ask for: one week can work if you only want strategic intentions and references, while a detailed proposal with a full scope and planning needs two to three weeks.
Should you share your budget in an RFP?
Yes. A range is enough. It lets agencies size their approach to what's realistic and makes proposals comparable, instead of forcing you to compare guesses.
Is a pitch fee necessary?
Only if you ask for creative work or significant strategic thinking. For a written proposal and a presentation of method, it isn't expected, but it always helps attract the best agencies.
What's the difference between an RFP and an RFI?
An RFI (request for information) collects general information to build a shortlist. An RFP (request for proposal) asks the shortlisted agencies for a detailed approach, team, timeline and price.
Can you skip the RFP entirely?
Yes, if you already know an agency whose work and method fit your needs. A paid discovery phase with one partner is often faster and more reliable than a competitive process.
What should you do next?
Block two hours with your decision makers this week and agree on the problem, the budget range, the timeline and who signs off. Then write a brief of four to six pages, and build your scoring grid before you send it.
Keep your shortlist to agencies you'd genuinely be happy to work with, ask for method rather than free creative, and close the loop with every agency once you've decided.
If you're preparing an RFP for a brand strategy, a visual identity or a website project and want a second pair of eyes on your brief, send us your draft: KLIMB is happy to give it a read.
Sources: FindGood client and agency pitch survey, reported by The Drum (2025); EACA, Cost of Pitching study (2025); PM Society, "The cost of pitching and the size of the prize"; 4A's, ANA and Advertiser Perceptions, The Cost of the Pitch (2023).
